Tag Archives: members project

Volunteer Wars: Members Project vs Tag!

I’m not sure when it suddenly became hip to give back…it was probably before Glee, but not that long ago. This month, two huge campaigns emerged to promote volunteering and civic engagement (plus some other things, as well).  Let’s take a look at what they did right and wrong:

Members Project

Sponsored by: Glee, American Express, Takepart

Purpose: Getting people involved by allowing them to vote for charities, find volunteer opportunities, and donate money

Exposure: Commercials during Glee, ads on facebook.com, extensive use of twitter

Perks of involvement: Opportunity to volunteer with the cast of Glee

Support: 508,201 fans on facebook

Tag! Get Hands On Challenge

Sponsored by: JetBlue Airlines, HandsOn Network

Purpose: Users “tag” friends to identify them as service leaders; sharing stories of service

Exposure: AmeriCorps Alums network, HandsOn community, user-initiated posts on facebook and twitter

Perks of Involvement: Chance to win an iPad or round-trip tickets on JetBlue

Support: 3,176 people “tagged”

Did you get that? 3,000 people compared to 500,000! And the one that has more engagement is the one where the prize is volunteering.  Ok, so it’s a chance to meet the Glee cast and fly to LA, too…but still.  Just for tagging a few friends you could get tickets to practically anywhere, so it isn’t just the trip.  And, you have to be 18+ for the Glee contest, so we are actually talking about somewhat rational people here.

To what can you attribute the success of the Members Project, then?  My guesses are as follows:

1) The Members Project utilizes an established fan base from Glee to grow support.  HandsOn’s initial base is very small in relative terms

2) Tangible reasons for engagement.  Sure, it’s great to be “tagged”, but the Members Project allows interaction and promotes tangible ways to take action and connect with service projects or charities.  The HandsOn campaign seems to be missing that – you can make a commitment and tell people about it, but it’s hard to find new and cool projects (the most popular commitment right now is to use reuseable shopping bags…not exactly a novel idea).

3) Ease of use.  With HandsOn, I’ve tried to tag about 200 people – no luck…a couple friends joined the site, but I wasn’t given credit for the “tag” (therefore, no prize).  With Members Project, all you need to do is connect via facebook.

4) Banter.  You want people to be talking to each other, right? Who doesn’t want to read (and comment on) the ongoing back-and-forth between Mr. Scheu and Sue? It keeps people coming back to the site, much more so than the relatively static journals associated with Tag.

Will Schuester It feels good to do good. But sometimes you just can’t make up your mind what kinda good you want to do:http://bit.ly/9UERCo November 16 at 12:49pm

Sue Sylvester Help Will Schuester (Glee) save the crocodiles. I need them for my vast shoe and handbag collection.http://bit.ly/WhoCares_IDont November 04 at 10:22am

Thanks to HandsOn and the Members Project for making it cool to care – good luck to each of you.  And for us volunteers? The best part is that we don’t have to choose, so sign up for both campaigns!


Leave a comment

Filed under Volunteer Opportunities